gkc cartoon

A lot of creativity in that belly…

Once upon a time not very long ago the civilized world eagerly read excellent stories by Catholic writers. The stories were everything that great literature is: captivating, intelligent, poignant, universal, liberating, but also imbued with a deeply Catholic sensibility.

The early and mid-twentieth century is the era I’m thinking of here. My personal list of favorites is topped by Flannery O’Connor, Graham Greene, J.R.R. Tolkien and G.K. Chesterton, but I know that you, TSOW reader, could add many more: A.J. Cronin, for instance, Evelyn Waugh…who am I missing?

And here’s something important to note about their books: they were read by everybody. There was no such thing as the “Christian fiction” section in bookstores. Readers were (and are) people of all faith backgrounds, or with no faith at all—they were simply lovers of fiction, and they considered the books of the above writers to be enriching and relevant, important as well as entertaining.

Another thing to note: the truth and goodness being conveyed by these novelists wasn’t ever saccharine or trite. Because truth and goodness aren’t saccharine and trite. In O’Connor and Green stories, in particular, we meet awful people doing terrible things; we discover hatred and prejudice and lust and murder. The great truth that Catholics want to transmit to the world includes (and doesn’t exclude) an encounter with all of that terrible stuff. If you prefer more modern fiction, check out Dean Koontz’s books—What the Night Knows, for instance. That’s a terrifying book, with evil characters committing atrocities, but Koontz, as usual, keeps the flame of hope and good burning at the heart of it, and it’s unmistakably Catholic (he even invents a new sacrament, only instead of the grace-giving vehicle being bread or wine or oil, it’s…Legos! Very nice.)

So, I don’t know what your summer reading is. No doubt there is plenty of non-fiction on your To-Read List, which is great. But don’t forget to include a good novel or novella. Other than prayer, there is no faster, more gut-level way to encounter truth, beauty and goodness.

The TSOW Recommended Reading List:

3 By Flannery O’Connor. IMPORTANT! There are plenty of Flannery O’Connor collections out there, but I link to this one because it is one of the few that has “A Good Man Is Hard to Find” WITH the St. Cyril of Jerusalem quote at the beginning. For some weird reason, a lot of versions omit the St. Cyril quote*, and I don’t know why because it provides a nice key for better understanding the story.

The Quiet American, by Graham Greene. The Power and the Glory is Greene’s best, but this one is no slacker. It’s gritty, passionate, and desperate, and all the characters turn out to be completely different than what you think at the beginning. Mrs. Moxie Wife didn’t like it, but I’m officially overruling her.

What the Night Knows, by Dean Koontz. I know his Odd Thomas series is really popular, but if you just want one really frightening, self-contained horror story, I liked this one a lot.

The Man Who Was Thursday, by G.K. Chesterton. I read this roughly once a year. It is a tremendously clever, funny, dark tale that will nearly take your breath away at the end with a pile of profound revelations. This Ignatius Press version has great annotations and original artwork by Chesterton himself!

And, of course, if you can wait until August 24, you can check out By the Downward Way by Yours Truly. As we speak, the TSOW gnomes are hard at work gluing the pages together. Soon I’ll even have a fabulous cover to show you AND a book trailer! Stay tuned, and happy reading!


Dan’s right! Come on, fellas–let’s go read some novels!

*The full quote by St. Cyril: “The dragon is by the side of the road, watching those who pass. Beware lest he devour you. We go to the Father of souls, but it is necessary to pass by the dragon.”

5 thoughts on “Do Stories Matter? A Summer Reading Appetizer

  1. Agreed. Haven’t read all in your list, but Chesterton by far takes the cake, in my opinion. Love ‘The Man Who was Thursday.’ ‘The Flying Inn’ is my next favorite, if for no other reason than Patrick’s insistence on rum-infused poetry as judged by the dog Quoodle.

    Perhaps it was the missing St. Cyril quote, but Flannery O’Connor… ohmysweetheaven, does that writer creep me out. I read ‘A Good Man is Hard to Find’ at the behest of my brother, who thinks she’s ah-mazing. I was a bit (okay, quite a bit) disturbed. Isn’t that the one where the guy ends up shooting the whole family in a ditch/in the woods or something? Maybe that was a different one, and A Good Man is the one with the deranged Bible salesman. Oh my. In any case, probably gave me nightmares, so I have yet to appreciate her particular style. 😉 There must be something about her, though, as I hear her works praised time and again. Perhaps I should revisit.

    Have you read any Robert Hugh Benson? I’ve heard that he was the writer who inspired Chesterton and many other contemporaries. I’ve only read ‘Come Rack, Come Rope!’, which you’ve probably heard of, but he has a lot of interesting/dark fiction, like ‘The Necromancers’, which I’ve heard are great. Apparently he also did the ‘first’ dystopian series, I think it’s called ‘The Lord of the World’.

    Interesting, informative, and witty post as usual, Dan. Glad to see Charlie’s nocturnals haven’t completely eaten your brain. 😀 Keep it up!

    • Hello Martha, and thanks for the comments. You know, my guess is that Flannery O’Connor is more of a man’s writer. It’s not just the grittiness and the disturbing stuff, but even the style seems to appeal more to men than to women. I wonder if the numbers back up that theory? I dunno…would any female Flannery fans out there like to chime in?

      I’ve only read Paradoxes of Catholicism by Benson–I’d forgotten that he wrote The Lord of the World series, and I didn’t even know about The Necromancers. Thanks for enlightening me!

    • Thanks, Martha! I read it, and I must respectfully disagree with the author because…he ain’t right. Anyway, that’s cool…she’s certainly not for everyone.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *